Whole pies may be pre-ordered from this list with 48 hours notice with the exception of holidays, but our shop selection varies each day.
All whole pies are baked in 9" glass pie plates which you may return at your convenience for a half price slice of pie!
PLEASE NOTE THAT WE DO NOT OFFER DELIVERY THROUGH ANY DELIVERY SERVICE (Uber Eats, Grub Hub, Door Dash, etc.)
All whole pies are baked in 9" glass pie plates which you may return at your convenience for a half price slice of pie!
PLEASE NOTE THAT WE DO NOT OFFER DELIVERY THROUGH ANY DELIVERY SERVICE (Uber Eats, Grub Hub, Door Dash, etc.)
PIEFALOOTIN'S ALWAYS INCOMPLETE PIE LIST
PIEFALOOTIN STYLE CREAM PIES
Banana Cream Pie - 45 (Banana cream pie with lots of bananas and mounds of fresh whipped cream)
Banana Split Pie - 45
Banoffee Pie - 45 (Bananas, Dulce de Leche, and a taste of our banana nut bread with walnuts)
Best of Both Swirls - 45 (Chocolate and vanilla cream perfectly swirled together)
Best of Both Worlds - 45 (Coconut and chocolate cream stacked to give you both in each slice)
Butterscotch Cream - 45 (Old fashioned flavor with fresh whipped cream)
Butterscotch Chocolate - 45 (Layers of our chocolate and butterscotch cream)
Chocolate Cream Pie - 45 (Our chocolate cream made with 5 kinds of chocolate and homemade whipped cream)
Chocolate EuphOREO - 45 (Chocolate cream with OREOS over and under!)
Chocolate Express - 45 (Our delicious brownies beneath chocolate cream and espresso whipped cream)
Chocolate Macadamia Nut - 45 (Chocolate cream over crumbled white chocolate macadamia cookies)
Chocolate WHOPPER - 45 (If you like Whoppers and malted milk you will love this pie!)
Cinco de PIE-yo - 45 (Chocolate cream over spicy brownies with cinnamon/cayenne whipped cream)
Coconut Cream Pie - 45 (Our special recipe topped with homemade whipping )
Espresso My Love - 45 (German chocolate espresso cream with coconut, pecans and chocolate whipped cream)
German Chocolate - 45 (You just thought German Chocolate cake was good - just wait!)
Neo-PIE-litan - 45 (That's right - 3 layers of Chocolate brownie, vanilla cream and strawberry puree with whipped cream)
Tella-Buddy - 45 (Nutty Buddies, Nutella and Chocolate Cream - delish!)
There's Always Money in the Banana Stand - 45 (Bananas and chocolate cream with chocolate covered peanuts)
Threat Level Midnight - 45 (Chocolate from top to bottom. Crazy good!)
What's Up Buttercup? - 45 (Chocolate Cream and peanut butter cups with peanut butter whipped cream)
White Chocolate EuphOREO - 45 (White chocolate cream with OREO cookies dipped in white chocolate)
You've Gotta Be Kit'n Me - 45 (Milk chocolate cream over crushed Kit Kat bars)
Zillionaire - 45 (Strawberries, pecans, coconut, pineapple, cream cheese, whipped cream - NOT your grandma's Millionaire!)
Banana Split Pie - 45
Banoffee Pie - 45 (Bananas, Dulce de Leche, and a taste of our banana nut bread with walnuts)
Best of Both Swirls - 45 (Chocolate and vanilla cream perfectly swirled together)
Best of Both Worlds - 45 (Coconut and chocolate cream stacked to give you both in each slice)
Butterscotch Cream - 45 (Old fashioned flavor with fresh whipped cream)
Butterscotch Chocolate - 45 (Layers of our chocolate and butterscotch cream)
Chocolate Cream Pie - 45 (Our chocolate cream made with 5 kinds of chocolate and homemade whipped cream)
Chocolate EuphOREO - 45 (Chocolate cream with OREOS over and under!)
Chocolate Express - 45 (Our delicious brownies beneath chocolate cream and espresso whipped cream)
Chocolate Macadamia Nut - 45 (Chocolate cream over crumbled white chocolate macadamia cookies)
Chocolate WHOPPER - 45 (If you like Whoppers and malted milk you will love this pie!)
Cinco de PIE-yo - 45 (Chocolate cream over spicy brownies with cinnamon/cayenne whipped cream)
Coconut Cream Pie - 45 (Our special recipe topped with homemade whipping )
Espresso My Love - 45 (German chocolate espresso cream with coconut, pecans and chocolate whipped cream)
German Chocolate - 45 (You just thought German Chocolate cake was good - just wait!)
Neo-PIE-litan - 45 (That's right - 3 layers of Chocolate brownie, vanilla cream and strawberry puree with whipped cream)
Tella-Buddy - 45 (Nutty Buddies, Nutella and Chocolate Cream - delish!)
There's Always Money in the Banana Stand - 45 (Bananas and chocolate cream with chocolate covered peanuts)
Threat Level Midnight - 45 (Chocolate from top to bottom. Crazy good!)
What's Up Buttercup? - 45 (Chocolate Cream and peanut butter cups with peanut butter whipped cream)
White Chocolate EuphOREO - 45 (White chocolate cream with OREO cookies dipped in white chocolate)
You've Gotta Be Kit'n Me - 45 (Milk chocolate cream over crushed Kit Kat bars)
Zillionaire - 45 (Strawberries, pecans, coconut, pineapple, cream cheese, whipped cream - NOT your grandma's Millionaire!)
PIEFALOOTIN CHEESECAKE PIES (Seasonal)
Blueberry Cheesecake Pie - 45
Strawberry Cheesecake Pie - 45
Blackberry Cheesecake Pie - 45
Red White & Blueberry Pie - 45
Caramel Turtle Cheesecake Pie - 45
OREO Cheesecake Pie - 45
Strawberry Cheesecake Pie - 45
Blackberry Cheesecake Pie - 45
Red White & Blueberry Pie - 45
Caramel Turtle Cheesecake Pie - 45
OREO Cheesecake Pie - 45
PIEFALOOTIN FRUITY PIES (Seasonal)
Blueberry Pie -45 (Seasonal)
Blackberry Cobbler Pie - 45 (Seasonal)
Apple Crumble Pie -45
Nutty Apple Crumble - 45
Waldorf Hysteria - 45 (Apples, walnuts, raisins and cranberries with brown sugar crumble on top)
Double Cherry Cherry Pie - 45
Cherry Jalapeno Pie -45
Peach Cobbler Pie -45
Classic Apple Pie - 45
Cherry Almond Crumble - 45
PIEFALOOTIN STYLE CLASSICS
Texas Pecan - 45
Chocolate Pecan - 45
Chocolate Espresso Pecan -45
Pumpkin -45
Key Lime -45
Buttermilk - 45
Lemon Icebox - 45
Lemon Chess - 45
Chocolate Pecan - 45
Chocolate Espresso Pecan -45
Pumpkin -45
Key Lime -45
Buttermilk - 45
Lemon Icebox - 45
Lemon Chess - 45
MORE PIEFALOOTIN ORIGINALS
Whiskey-Tango - 45 (Buttermilk pie with whiskey, rum, and a pecan praline topping)
Butter Rum - 45 (Buttermilk is even better with rum!)
Derby Pie - 45 (Chocolate walnut pie with a splash of bourbon)
Lemon Berry Blues - 45 (Our delicious Lemon Icebox with a blueberry twist!)
Oops! I did it again - hiccup! - 45 (Scoops of buttermilk and chocolate brownies with bourbon pecan poured over the top)
Hello Dolly - 45 (Layers of chocolate, graham cracker, coconut, pecans and cream cheese gooey goodness)
White Chocolate Macadamia Brownie Pie - 45 (A gooey white chocolate brownie style with coconut and macadamias)
Ah, Man, JOY! - 45 (Cream cheese & coconut between layers of dark chocolate with chocolate & almonds)
Punkin Awesome! - 40 (A new experience in pumpkin with all the holiday spices, raisins, and a root beer walnut glaze)
Chocolate Walnut Brownie Pie - 45 ( A gooey fudgy brownie pie with walnuts & chocolate buttercream drizzle)
Chocolate Pecan Brownie Pie - 45 (The same rich brownie pie with pecans & chocolate buttercream drizzle)
Peanut Butter Cookie Pie - 45 (Our special peanut butter brownie pie with peanut butter buttercream and cookies)
Caramel Sawdust Pie - 45 (Like a big Samoa cookie, only better!)
Orange You Happy It's Not Key Lime - 45 (Made like our Key Lime only orange - think Orange Creamsicle)
Strawberry Buttermilk - 45 (Our delicious buttermilk with strawberry topping and white chocolate)
Blueberry Buttermilk - 45 (You guessed it! Our buttermilk pie is fabulous with our special blueberry topping)
Blackberry Buttermilk - 45 (No need to explain)
Raspberry Buttermilk - 45 (Exactly)
Butter Rum - 45 (Buttermilk is even better with rum!)
Derby Pie - 45 (Chocolate walnut pie with a splash of bourbon)
Lemon Berry Blues - 45 (Our delicious Lemon Icebox with a blueberry twist!)
Oops! I did it again - hiccup! - 45 (Scoops of buttermilk and chocolate brownies with bourbon pecan poured over the top)
Hello Dolly - 45 (Layers of chocolate, graham cracker, coconut, pecans and cream cheese gooey goodness)
White Chocolate Macadamia Brownie Pie - 45 (A gooey white chocolate brownie style with coconut and macadamias)
Ah, Man, JOY! - 45 (Cream cheese & coconut between layers of dark chocolate with chocolate & almonds)
Punkin Awesome! - 40 (A new experience in pumpkin with all the holiday spices, raisins, and a root beer walnut glaze)
Chocolate Walnut Brownie Pie - 45 ( A gooey fudgy brownie pie with walnuts & chocolate buttercream drizzle)
Chocolate Pecan Brownie Pie - 45 (The same rich brownie pie with pecans & chocolate buttercream drizzle)
Peanut Butter Cookie Pie - 45 (Our special peanut butter brownie pie with peanut butter buttercream and cookies)
Caramel Sawdust Pie - 45 (Like a big Samoa cookie, only better!)
Orange You Happy It's Not Key Lime - 45 (Made like our Key Lime only orange - think Orange Creamsicle)
Strawberry Buttermilk - 45 (Our delicious buttermilk with strawberry topping and white chocolate)
Blueberry Buttermilk - 45 (You guessed it! Our buttermilk pie is fabulous with our special blueberry topping)
Blackberry Buttermilk - 45 (No need to explain)
Raspberry Buttermilk - 45 (Exactly)